Skip to main content

5 Advantages of Allowing Pets In a Rental Property

5 Advantages of Allowing Pets In a Rental Property

The Advantages of Pets in a Rental Property

A black pug wearing a cozy knit sweater, sitting against a vibrant yellow background with a serious yet adorable expression.

The decision to allow pets in a rental property is a significant one for landlords. Many landlords and investors ask 'should I allow pets in my rental property?'   

A choice that can impact various aspects of property management exists. From tenant satisfaction to turnover costs, the implications are far-reaching. 

Yet, an increasing number of landlords are embracing pet-friendly policies. Are you on the fence about allowing pets in your rental property?   

In this article, we delve into the advantages of allowing pets in investment properties and how it benefits your rental business. We explore how it can benefit landlords, property owners, and real estate investors.

The benefits range from expanding your prospective tenant pool to enhancing community satisfaction.    

Join us as we unpack the five key advantages of adopting a pet-friendly approach in your rental property.

1. Expanded Tenant Pool  

One of the most significant advantages of allowing pets in your rental property is the larger tenant pool. Tenants with pets are certainly looking for rental property with pets accepted. If all possible, it's a good idea to have pet-friendly real estate.

A large percentage of renters own pets. By having a pet-friendly policy, you open your doors to these potential tenants.   

This can significantly lower your property's vacancy rates. Simple math shows that more potential tenants mean fewer vacant units.

Consider the following:

  • A significant percentage of households in the U.S. own pets. Florida is the third-most populated state and has 12.5 million pet owners.      

  • Many of these pet owners struggle to find pet-friendly rentals.      

  • By allowing pets, you cater to this underserved market.

In essence, a pet-friendly policy can make your property more appealing to a broader range of renters. This can lead to quicker turnovers and fewer vacant units.

2. Increased Revenue Opportunities

Another advantage of allowing pets in your rental property is the potential for increased revenue.

Pet-friendly properties often command a premium in rent. This is because pet owners are typically willing to pay more for the convenience of living with their pets. 

Consider the following:    

  • You can charge a non-refundable pet fee to cover potential property maintenance and damage caused by pets.    

  • You can also implement a monthly pet rent, and other pet fees providing an additional income stream.      

  • Pet deposits serve as an extra safety measure to ensure coverage for any pet-related damages.

These additional fees and charges can significantly boost your rental income. 

In conclusion, allowing pets in your rental property can open new revenue opportunities, leading to higher profits.

3. Longer Tenant Retention

A third advantage of allowing pets in your rental property is longer tenant retention. 

Tenants with pets tend to stay longer in their rental homes. This is because finding pet-friendly rentals can be challenging, so once they find one, they are likely to stay put.

Consider the following:

  • Longer tenancies mean less turnover, saving you time and money on advertising and reletting costs.    

  • It also means fewer periods of vacancy, ensuring a steady stream of rental income.      

  • Tenants who stay longer are more likely to take care of the property, as they view it as their home. 

In essence, allowing pets can lead to longer tenant retention, reducing turnover costs and ensuring a steady rental income.

Allowing pets in your rental property can help with tenant retention, reducing the hassles associated with constant tenant turnover. 

4. Enhanced Community and Tenant Satisfaction

Allowing pets in a rental property can also elevate sense of community and tenant satisfaction.

Pets can contribute to a sense of community in a rental property. They can serve as ice-breakers, fostering interactions among tenants.

Consider the following:     

  • Pets can contribute to the mental and emotional well-being of tenants, leading to happier residents.

  • A pet-friendly environment can foster a sense of community, making the property more appealing to potential tenants.    

  • Happy tenants are more likely to renew their leases, helping with better turnover rates. 

Allowing pets can create a sense of community, improving overall tenant satisfaction. 

A pet-friendly rental property is extremely beneficial. It can foster a sense of community and enhance tenant satisfaction, leading to a more harmonious living environment.

A close-up of a white and gray cat with striking blue eyes, looking upwards against a soft, blurred background.

5. Competitive Advantage in Your Market  

Pet-friendly rentals can provide a competitive edge in the real estate market.

They can make a property stand out and attract many renters.

Consider the following: 

  • Pet-friendly properties can stand out in a crowded rental market, attracting more potential tenants.

  • Offering pet-friendly amenities, such as dog parks or pet washing stations, can increase property value.  
        
  • Pet-friendly rentals can benefit from partnerships with local pet businesses and services, further enhancing their appeal.

Allowing pets can make a rental property more unique and competitive, attracting a wider range of potential tenants.

In conclusion, a pet-friendly rental property can provide a competitive edge in the market. Helping set apart from other properties and attracting a larger pool of potential tenants.

Crafting a Balanced Pet Policy

Creating a clear pet policy is key when allowing pets in a rental property.

This policy spells out what you expect from pet owners and helps reduce possible problems.

Consider the following:    

  • A well-crafted pet policy can help in screening and selecting responsible pet owners.      

  • Landlords can set breed or size restrictions to manage potential risks associated with certain pets. Set a policy to meet the pet if necessary.    
      
  • Regular property inspections can ensure that pet-owning tenants maintain the rental unit.  

  • Clear common area rules and regulations.    

  • Clear communication between landlords and pet-owning tenants is essential for a successful pet policy.

A set pet policy is a key component of a successful pet-friendly rental property. It manages potential risks, sets clear expectations, and fosters a positive relationship between landlords and pet-owning tenants.

Assistance Animals

Assistance animals are crucial for individuals with disabilities in rental houses. This is because federal laws see these animals as essential aids, not just pets, for people with disabilities.

The Fair Housing Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act require landlords to accommodate tenants with assistance animals. These animals provide essential support for the individual. Whether it’s a guide dog for someone who can’t see well or an emotional support animal for someone with mental health needs.

Denying access to assistance animals is illegal under federal law. Property owners and managers should understand and follow these laws. This allows fair and equal housing opportunities for all.

Working With a Property Management Company

Working with an Orlando property management company will allow you to find a broader pool of tenants. They have clear pet restrictions, understand risks for certain types of pets, and understand local laws and federal housing laws. 

They will be able to review the pros and cons of allowing pets. They will help you figure out rental rates for pets, whether dogs and cats. Most importantly address within the lease agreement the terms surrounding a long term pet. No matter what property type, their resources usually allow you to get a higher rent. 

Contact us today to see how we can help get your property leased, a review if allowing a pet is right for you! 


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs): Allowing Pets in Your Rental

Why should landlords consider allowing pets in their rental properties?

Allowing pets in rental properties attracts more tenants, reduces vacancies, and enables higher rent pricing. Responsible pet owners often stay longer, decreasing turnover costs. Pet-friendly rentals also increase tenant satisfaction and broaden the applicant pool, making it easier to find reliable renters.

Can landlords charge extra fees for tenants with pets?

Yes, landlords can charge extra fees for tenants with pets, including pet deposits, pet rent, or non-refundable pet fees. However, fees must comply with local laws, and service animals cannot incur additional charges under the Fair Housing Act (FHA). Always check state and municipal regulations before setting pet fees.

Do tenants with pets stay longer in rental properties?

Yes, tenants with pets tend to stay longer in rental properties. Pet-friendly housing is harder to find, making tenants less likely to move. Longer stays reduce turnover costs and vacancy rates for landlords, increasing overall rental stability and profitability.

How can landlords reduce the risks of allowing pets?

Landlords can reduce pet-related risks by setting clear pet policies, requiring pet deposits or fees, and screening tenants with pets. Limiting pet size or breed, requiring renter’s insurance with pet coverage, and conducting regular property inspections help minimize damage and liability concerns.

What’s the difference between pets and assistance animals?

Pets are companion animals kept for enjoyment, while assistance animals (service animals and emotional support animals) provide disability-related support. Under the Fair Housing Act (FHA), assistance animals are not considered pets, so landlords cannot charge pet fees or impose pet restrictions on them.

How can Allegiant Management Group help landlords implement a pet-friendly policy?

Allegiant Management Group helps landlords implement pet-friendly policies by screening tenants with pets, setting clear lease agreements, and managing pet deposits or fees. They ensure compliance with local laws, conduct property inspections, and minimize risks while maximizing rental appeal and profitability.


Disclaimer: The information provided is for general information and education purposes only and is not legal advice. I am not an attorney. For legal advice, please consult a qualified attorney. This information does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Blog Updated: 03/08/2025

back